RHS Main Daffodil Show 14/15 April 2015

A2919A2876Although due to unseen circumstances it was a two hour dash round the show with camera and a failing memory for names (flowers and people), my impression was that it was a good show with two really outstanding classes shown on the right. (Click on the photographs to expand)

Richard Gillings achieved a record- breaking fourth successive win of the Bowles Cup with 15 vases of three from at least four divisions; he still has a further three wins to achieve in order to beat Tony Noton’s total number of successes. In second place was Ken Harrop with an entry which, although it perhaps lacked the wow factor of Richard’s, on individual examination of the individual vases it ran it very close.

The Richardson Trophy had five very good entries with the winning three below.

Richardson Trophy First Dave Spencer
Richardson Trophy
First
Dave Spencer
Richardson Trophy Second Ken Harrop
Richardson Trophy
Second
Ken Harrop
Richardson Trophy Third Ian Johnson
Richardson Trophy
Third
Ian Johnson

Highlighting these two classes allows me to make a point which has concerned me for the past ten years. The RHS is out of step with all the other main UK daffodil shows in not displaying the points awarded to each flower or vase in the main collection classes. In the Bowles Cup this was done, but in the Richardson Trophy it was not. How can we hope to explain to the visiting public and equally importantly the exhibitors themselves why one exhibit is better than another if there is no record of the assessed value of the flowers and their presentation. It is said that it would cause controversy; but there already is controversy and although one might not agree with the points awarded at least one would  know how the judge saw the relative values of the individual flowers. I rest my case.

Many of the first-time visitors are drawn to the classes for miniature flowers and there were plenty to see at this show. It is always a good sign for a newish exhibitor when they manage to beat their mentor at a major show. Here Linda English achieved it with a pristine superbly staged entry in the six vases of three miniatures. The prizes seemed to be well spread out in this section, even Frankie Charlton won a first prize and there was me thinking he only grew them to photograph them for his catalogue.  A few photographs from this section are below.

6 x 3 Miniatures Linda English (RH) Terry Braithwaite (LH)
6 x 3 Miniatures
Linda English (RH)
Terry Braithwaite (LH)
3 x 3 Miniatures Frankie Charlton Second from left
3 x 3 Miniatures
Frankie Charlton
Second from left
3 x 3 species Brian Duncan Left
3 x 3 species
Brian Duncan
Left

Along the side of the tent was a display of magnolias and other flowers which together with other photographs are shown below. Congratulations to our northern exhibitors Ken Harrop and Frankie Charlton for doing so well against very tough opposition. I always try to feature a few flowers which are new to the north and one to watch for is a 2W-W shown by Roger Braithwaite seedling 895 (Barbara Ann). Its photo is next to three others rarely seen in our region (only joking lads).
Please feel free to add your comments pointing out what I missed etc. using the reply facility at the bottom of this post.

Judging Best Blooms Left to right Reg, Malcolm, John
Judging Best Blooms
Left to right
Reg, Malcolm, John
Best Bloom in show Ian Johnson Moon Shadow
Best Bloom in show
Ian Johnson
Moon Shadow
Best Bloom Div 2 ? ?
Best Bloom Div 2
?
?
Best Bloom Div 1 Ken Harrop Paean
Best Bloom Div 1
Ken Harrop
Paean
Best Bloom Div 4 Fred Austin Jersey Roundabout
Best Bloom Div 4
Fred Austin
Jersey Roundabout
Best Miniature Brian Duncan N. graellsii
Best Miniature
Brian Duncan
N. graellsii
The Engleheart Cup Winner Brian Duncan
The Engleheart Cup
Winner
Brian Duncan
Six seedlings Winner Jeremy Wilkes
Six seedlings
Winner
Jeremy Wilkes
6 x 3 White Winner Ken Harrop
6 x 3 White
Winner
Ken Harrop
1W-W Roger Braithwaite Nightflight
1W-W
Roger Braithwaite
Nightflight
1W-Y Macdalla Ian Johnson
1W-Y
Macdalla
Ian Johnson
2Y-Y Brian Duncan Gold Ingot
2Y-Y
Brian Duncan
Gold Ingot
1Y-P Brian Duncan BD3320
1Y-P
Brian Duncan
BD3320
2W-W Seedling 895 Roger Braithwaite
2W-W
Seedling 895
Roger Braithwaite
Richard Gillings L Ian Johnson C Dave Spencer R
Richard Gillings L
Ian Johnson C
Dave Spencer R
The Ridleys
The Ridleys
The Richardsons
The Richardsons
Jeff English
Jeff English
Roger Braithwaite
Roger Braithwaite
The Charltons
The Charltons
Richard Gillings
Richard Gillings
Dave Vivash L Brian Duncan R
Dave Vivash L
Brian Duncan R
Magnolias etc in show tent
Magnolias etc
in show tent
Narcissus bulbocodium on Wisley Hill
Narcissus bulbocodium
on Wisley Hill

2 thoughts on “RHS Main Daffodil Show 14/15 April 2015”

  1. Thank you James for doing such a comprehensive and well illustrated report so quickly. I thought the blooms on show were mostly very clean and fresh and as always there were some interesting flowers, including three white and orange trumpets shown by Brian Duncan. Not yet the best show form but the orange coloring was both deep and clear in each case. It was also good to see so many members of the public enjoying the show and taking an interest in the daffodils.

  2. I appreciate the need for points to be shown but am not sure of its value. I was introduced to pointing flowers at one of the main English shows. The three judges for the main class were of the highest profile in the Daffodil Society. We decided which collection would be first, second and third then went about giving points. When we got to the fifth placed entry there was one superb flower in the entry to which the judges gave 5 points. I took it and placed it beside a nine pointer in the first placed entry and asked which was the better flower to which they responded by giving the lowest placed flower 5 and a half points.
    In other words points were awarded to justify the class placing, not the quality of the flower.
    I have been sceptical of pointing flowers ever since and am not convinced that displaying the points cards would actually add to our information.

    David Adams

Comments are closed.